Written by The Student Staff    Sunday, 15 May 2011 14:21   
University cashes in on internships
News

_51183128_holyrood_money

THE UNIVERSITY of Edinburgh has made more £1m from courses promising enrolled international exchange students a Holyrood internship, it was revealed today.

The Sunday Herald alleges that the University's Institute of Governance (IOG) has made £1.7m from its Parliamentary Internship Programme, which charges more than £5000 for a 15 week course which guarantees students an internship with an MSP. Figures disclosed via a Freedom of Information request show that the course has expanded considerably since its inception in 1999, with fees increasing from £3640 to £5560, the number of places growing five-fold from from 8 to 40 and the annual income from the scheme tripling from £69,160 to £222,400 per year.

In the first weeks of the programme, students on their year abroad from other universities enrol on three courses offered by the College of Humanities and Social Science, said to provide students with "a background in British Politics and the specific nature of Scottish politics, society and culture".

A fortnight transition period sees the coursework handed-in and preparations for the Parliamentary placement finalised.The courses are followed with an eight week internship with MSPs and a research project on a topic decided upon between the MSP, the intern and the Director of Studies is undertaken at the same time.· Students return to the IOG for a weekly one day compulsory session.

Since the first session of the Parliament in 1999, 300 students in twenty groups have completed the programme. Those enrolling in the programme have been mainly from the US, but some have also come from Germany, Australia, Canada and the Netherlands. More than half of the 129 MSPs in previous parliaments have participated.

Participating MSPs include independent Lothians MSP Margo MacDonald, former Scottish Labour leader Wendy Alexander and her deputy, Cathy Jamieson; potential Labour leadership contender Jackie Baillie; Conservative Education spokeswoman Elizabeth Smith; controversial tory Justice Committee Convener Bill Aitken; the SNP's Aileen Campbell and Bob Doris, and Liberal Democrats Jamie Stone - described as a "stalwart" of the scheme by the IOG - and the party's former leader, Tavish Scott.

Students appear to enrol on the course in the hope that it will provide a boost to their CVs, with one participant commenting, "The ability to watch and work with a politician…was an ideal experience. I would recommend the entire experience to any person who has an ounce of drive and desire to work or understand the Parliamentary system. This was not just an internship that will polish up my resumé, but a work experience that I will always be aiming to duplicate."

The IOG website reports that Bob Doris (SNP, Glasgow) harboured scepticism of the scheme at first, changing his mind after ten weeks with his intern and reporting that MSPs were "queuing up for interns".

His party colleague John Wilson (Central Scotland), however, slammed the University's role in the scheme, saying, "Edinburgh University has a lot of explaining to do, as it appears to be using its privileged position to profit from the Parliament. I would imagine there are many MSPs who do not know that these interns are paying for their places". An MSP who accepted an intern in the last session of Parliament said, "I knew nothing about the fee".

A Holyrood source said: "This scheme makes a mockery of the Parliament's founding principles of transparency and equal opportunities for all.· The new presiding officer needs to decide if she· is comfortable with an arrangement which allows money in return for providing access to MSPs and Parliament staff".

Ben Lyons, co-director of the pressure group Intern Aware also criticised the scheme, pointing out that, "If unpaid internships continue, 20 years down the line the country's political, cultural and business class will be made solely of those who could afford to work for free in 2011 - and in the case of MSPs, those who could afford to pay to work."

The scheme has confused some full-time Edinburgh students, who were disappointed to learn that the course is not open to students completing a degree at the University.

One student, who asked not to be named, spoke to their Director of Studies at the start of this academic year to ask whether they could enrol in the course and was told that it is not open to regular students because it would not allow them to complete the required courses needed to receive their degree.

"I thought the course would augment my degree, but it seems that the University would rather take foreign students on a junket than provide this course for home students," the student said.

"As a politics student, I was disappointed that I was not allowed to take the course, especially as I have since met some American students in the programme who seem to have little to no idea how the Scottish Parliament works or even a basic understanding of the party divisions."

The revelations come after it emerged that the Conservative party auctioned-off internships at leading financial institutions, PR companies and multinational companies for up to £3000 in order to raise party funds.· Coalition partner Nick Clegg subsequently went on the offensive over unpaid internships, saying "For too long, internships have been the almost exclusive preserve of the sharp-elbowed. Unfair, informal internships can rig the market in favour of thsoe who already have opportunities" and calling for competitive advertisement and "proper renumeration" as the solution. 

The IOG, EUSA and the Scottish Parliament have been contacted for comment.

The IOG website list the following MSPs as particpants:

SNP: Bill Kidd, Michael Matheson, Alasdair Allan, Jamie Hepburn, Rob Gibson, Aileen Campbell, Kenneth Gibson, Stuart McMillan, Nigel Don, Bob Doris.

Labour: Jackie Baillie, Frank McAveety, David Whitton, Helen Eadie, Margaret Curran, Michael McMahon, Cathy Jamieson, Wendy Alexander, David Stewart, Rhona Brankin, Marlyn Glen, Rhoda Grant, Richard Simpson.

Conservative: Ted Brocklebank, John Lamont, Mary Scanlon, Elizabeth Smith, Bill Aitken.

Liberal Democrat: Jamie Stone, Tavish Scott.

Independent: Margo MacDonald.

Comments
Add New Search
Source?
Mike Williamson (92.236.26.xxx) 2011-05-15 23:58:46

Do you have a link to the original story? Can't find it on the Herald website.
Cheers
Editors (193.130.15.xxx) 2011-05-16 15:50:14

@Mike Williamson - They didn't publish it on their website.
Anonymous (129.67.50.xxx) 2011-05-16 19:12:50

It's online now.
T (71.226.115.xxx) 2011-05-16 19:37:06

As a former participant in this program, I find it deeply saddening that these
attacks are being made with little understanding of why some aspects of the
program are the way they are.

First, regarding the internship being
unpaid:
Many American universities (including my own) are very uneasy about the
idea of a student gaining academic credit for an internship for which they are
also paid. I don't understand this fear (in fact, I find it ridiculous), but the
fact remains that keeping the internship unpaid on the Parliamentary side of
things ensures that credit is received for the internship.

Second, regarding
the intern's initial knowledge of the intricacies of Scottish Politics:
The
purpose of the program is to familiarize the students/interns with the Scottish
political system. To expect them to have a comprehensive understanding of the
system before, or even halfway through, the internship is simply ridiculous.


Thi...
T (71.226.115.xxx) 2011-05-16 19:41:40

Sorry the rest got cut off.

American students do this program to gain an
understanding of the system. Anyone suggesting they shouldn't be allowed to
participate because they lacked a complete understanding beforehand simply has
an axe to grind.

Third, the cost isn't absurdly high. It is roughly equal to
half of the university's fees for international students. The fact that
international students fees are high is nothing new.
T (71.226.115.xxx) 2011-05-16 19:46:19

Fourth,
The idea stated by "christin" that American students wishing to
intern in the parliament should have connections to get in "the back
door" is absurd. Unlike domestic students who would have the opportunity to
gain such connections through working on a campaign or in a constituency office.
Is the suggestion really that no international students should be able to intern
in the parliament?
T (71.226.115.xxx) 2011-05-16 19:52:08

Finally,

I can speak for those in my cohort when I say that this program has
created a group of american students with an understanding of the Scottish
Political system. It has created a group of students who head back to their home
campuses and communities and promote Scotland. If the author of this article and
some of those commenting are really suggesting that Scotland and the parliament
would be better off without those ambassadors abroad, then that is their
prerogative. However, let me call it as I see it: that cynicism and skepticism
of the qualifications/intentions of foreign students reeks is deeply offensive
and unfortunate.
To "T": read.Then rant!
Christin (2.98.86.xxx) 2011-05-16 21:07:06

To "T":
in my comment I was spilling some general criticism over both
the nepotism in the selection process for parliamentary internship programmes in
general (aka. "back door"), AND the commercialisation evident in
Edinburgh Uni's practise of "selling" them to North American exchange
students ("golden key").
"Christin": I did.
T (71.226.115.xxx) 2011-05-16 22:23:28

"Christin"
I did read it. And its a fair point on the back door comment.
I misunderstood your original point. I apologise if I misquoted you in my
response. However, the second point is still, I feel, an unfair one. This
article, as well as the Herald article, conveniently ignores the amount of
academic work done as a part of this internship and Edinburgh Uni's role in that
work. Any international student would be paying roughly that amount for a
semester's worth of credit from the University. So they are not
"selling" those places. They are asking market value for a semester's
worth of academic work/credit.
editors (Publisher) 2011-05-16 23:43:09

Dear T

At no point does the article suggest that internships are being
"sold" by the university. All the article does is draw attention to the
amount of money that the university has made from these courses.

It is not
accurate to suggest that the article does not mention that academic work is part
of the course. There are references to this in the third and four paragraphs.
James (129.215.149.xxx) 2011-05-16 23:46:53

Your point about the internships being paid meaning that students could not use
the course as college credit is a fair one, but I think it misses the point of
why so many people are outraged about this. It isn't so much because the interns
are not paid as none of them are -whether on the course or not - but that a
payment by the student guarantees them a place when a student without such money
might have a more difficult time of getting a parliamentary internship.
Editors:
T (71.226.115.xxx) 2011-05-17 05:13:34

Dear Editors:

My response to the accusation that "selling" was
occurring was to a fellow comment, not the article. If you look back at one of
"christin"'s responses you will find that they mention
"selling".
T (71.226.115.xxx) 2011-05-17 05:22:59

On the point reagarding the academic work, you are correct. My response was too
strongly worded. Your explanation of the academic work was far more
comprehensive than the Herald's.

That said, mentioning the
"auctioning" practice of the Conservative Party in this article suggests
that this is a part of the same issue/problem. That seems unfair to me. In that
case, internships were paid for. Why even mention it?
To James:
T (71.226.115.xxx) 2011-05-17 05:25:37

I think the problem here is the lack of access for domestic students. It seems
to me that that justifies the creation of a parliament sponsored internship
programme rather than the elimination of the only way that international
students can gain the contacts necessarily to intern.
Research
Sean (79.135.102.xxx) 2011-06-22 11:32:08

I'm doing some research into unpaid internships and keen to speak to anyone who
is currently or about to start interning. Please email sean@snappertv.co.uk
or ring 020 7428 8721 (anonymously if you prefer)
Write comment
Name:
Email:
 
Title:

3.26 Copyright (C) 2008 Compojoom.com / Copyright (C) 2007 Alain Georgette / Copyright (C) 2006 Frantisek Hliva. All rights reserved."


Related news items:
Newer news items:
Older news items: