Scotland needs to remain united in the face of a second referendum

The 18 September 2014 was an important day for Scotland. It was the date of the Scottish Independence referendum and marked the end of long, passionate and hostile campaigns from both sides. Intimidation and violence were rife in the months prior to the referendum. That can’t happen again. If the people of Scotland decide to hold another referendum, it needs to be different.

Between Catalonia’s independence crisis and growing uncertainty surrounding the UK’s Brexit deal, it’s looking increasingly likely that Scotland will hold another independence referendum: when this will happen, however, is less clear. Speaking to STV News, Nicola Sturgeon – the First Minister of Scotland – said of a future referendum: “I will not consider the timescale until there is greater clarity about the Brexit talks.”

The topic of Scottish Independence is undeniably controversial, with most Scots having a strong opinion about the referendum and its results. The debate significantly increased political participation, as evidenced by the huge turnout of voters: 84.6 per cent. Political engagement is vital and both debate and discussion should be encouraged. However, disagreeing with an individual’s politics is no excuse to threaten or commit a crime against them.  

I grew up in a rural village in the North of Scotland and experienced the divisive nature of the referendum first hand. Some families in the village would stop speaking to others, there were multiple physical assaults, and incidents of bullying in our Primary school when a child expressed an unpopular opinion regarding the upcoming vote.

The intimidation was not limited to voters; campaigners, politicians and journalists were all targeted. The National Union of Journalists (NUJ) released a statement condemning the abuse received by their members: “The NUJ has expressed concern at the increase in intimidation and bullying of journalists covering the independence referendum and calls for people on both sides of the campaign to rein in the abuse being directed at our members.”

The NUJ continued by expressing their concern about the impact that the abuse could have on the referendum’s legitimacy. “More widely, the NUJ asks the leadership on both sides to consider carefully the implications of their attacks on journalists for asking challenging questions. If that is to be interpreted as bias, and therefore the journalist is deemed to be open to personal criticism and abuse, then the nature of public debate will be debased, and we will all suffer.”

Intimidating somebody to ensure that they vote a certain way, or keep quiet about an issue they’re passionate about, directly undermines the democratic ideals that were behind the first referendum.  For the results to be legitimate, voters need to feel able to participate without fear. Disagreements regarding Scottish Independence are inevitable, but they should be resolved with debate, not violence.

The first Scottish referendum tore Scotland in half and a second has the potential to do the same. We need to ensure that this doesn’t happen. Whether or not Scotland exits the UK, Scots need to remain united.

Related News

3 Responses

Leave a Reply
  1. Peter Davidson
    Oct 31, 2017 - 09:13 AM

    Scotland is less united today than it has been for generations thanks to the deliberate programme of division enacted by the nationalists. Nationalism forces people to choose Us or Them. People who are ‘Us’ must do as they are told. People who are ‘Them’ are the enemy. There is no road to a united, independent Scotland from here. ‘Independence’ as defined by nationalists is a supremacist’s dream where one group dominates the other in perpetuity; this will not be tolerated. Further attempts by nationalists to steal the rights and freedoms of free scots will only drive Scotland further down the road taken by Ulster. There will not be another referendum, only more division. Nationalism is not OK. Scots need to stop doffing their cap to the new nationalist aristocracy

    Reply
  2. Hank McDonald
    Oct 31, 2017 - 04:42 PM

    I agree with the premise of the article but the fact is the British ruling elite have been stoking tensions between different communities and keeping people on these isles divided for over the past 300 years on purpose, it’s how they ensure their own survival, don’t expect it to end anytime soon. Have a look at Ireland, Iraq and Afghanistan. The British Empire never ended. Unionism in Scotland has become nothing short of an inferiority complex. A true united Scotland can only ever exist post independence. If booting people out of the country simply because they’re different is what it means to be ‘British’ then I don’t want it.

    “Divide and Conquer.”

    ― Gaius Julius Caesar.

    Reply
    • Peter Davidson
      Nov 06, 2017 - 08:44 PM

      Is this meant to be ironic? Scottish ‘Independence’ is all about the rejection/ejection of people simply because they are different; anyone not identifying with the cliched ‘Scottish’ identity religiously promoted by the nationalists is to be excluded/purged/detoxed. The fundamental premise of the entire ‘Independence’ movement is to create division – Us and Them. Nationalist Scotland has dug deep into the well of smallminded parochial bigotry, division and racism that was buried centuries ago by the supra-national idea of the british union. Some things are left buried; better left in the past.
      ‘British’ is a Natty synonym for English. Anyone but England say racists. Scotland can only be pure once it has been racially separate from the English untermensch say the racists. In the twisted logic of backwoods natty scotland it all makes sense. In the civilised world it is just racism; a deliberate attempt to divide and rule by a bigoted and self-obsessed clique. There will not be a second referendum because the notion of trust and respect between people in Scotland has been destroyed by the nationalists. Never again. They are not democrats and hence do not deserve democracy

      Reply

Say something

The Student Newspaper 2016

IMPORTANT NOTICE FOR THE STUDENT WRITERS, past and present:
The newspaper is currently exploring transitioning to a new website. In this eventuality, there may be a loss of content. Writers are reminded to keep an archival copy of their own work.
Follow the Student on Facebook for more information.
+